29 Apr 2021

Public Sector Automation: Expectation vs Reality

Richard Clarke, Director at Fivium, highlights some of the misconceptions about automation in the public sector as part of techUK’s Intelligent Automation Week.

In my role as Director at Fivium, I have witnessed first-hand over the last year the relentless tsunami of cases that have flooded central government ministerial, parliamentary and information rights teams as the COVID crisis has washed over all of us.

The effect of this, sometimes fourfold, increase in workloads at a time when normal routines, working conditions and capacity have all been dramatically changed is understandably monumental and not without repercussions; however, these teams have universally stepped up to the challenge, often working late at night and at weekends just to keep up with the demand for timely information to keep parliament, industry and the public as best informed as possible over this unprecedented period.

The Utopian Vision of Automation

The best innovation typically comes from times of hardship, therefore it isn’t surprising to see interest in how and where automation can eliminate manual or repetitive tasks and where technology can augment people to create further efficiencies.

What is perhaps unsurprising is that the main drive for automation seems to be coming from the technology function rather than the business user community; however, this is dangerous because whilst simple transactions are relatively easy to automate, complex ones require a deep understanding of often very nuanced context and end to end business processes. The risk is that business users are sold a utopian vision, which leads them to believing that third party tooling can be a one size fits all solution, when in fact it is not. Rather than alleviating workload pressures, it instead creates new management workloads (via maintenance of new numerous complex and unwieldy data repositories that manage their new ‘automation’) or ends up causing confusion and chaos when even slightly ambiguous transactions are misdirected through intricately designed workflows. For true automation to be successful, it can not be entered into as a tick box exercise, it needs to be well thought out and consider the future implications of system changes.

Simple or Complex Automation?

Therefore, I advocate that rather than rush headlong into looking for tactical problems for third party generic ‘task automation’ solutions to solve, government really considers the end-to-end complexity of the processes that its under pressure business functions are carrying out, such as its correspondence teams (but there will no doubt be a myriad of other ones too!). If the process is straightforward, with few limited variables, then generic ‘task automation’ multi-purpose solutions are exactly the right tool for the job. However, if the process is complex, with significant amounts of variability and cannot be easily broken down into a series of simple tasks, then it is likely that deep business domain knowledge and experience will be needed. The best and most efficient way of sourcing that is to collaborate with the experts in the specific business function field to truly innovate. This may initially incur a perceived higher overhead, as rather than working with a single generic ‘task automation’ vendor, government departments will need to engage their existing and/ or potentially future system providers for each complex process. Working directly with Fivium’s eCase customer community has enabled us to see, first-hand, the benefits of collaboration between organisations and service providers with unique domain knowledge. This approach has proven to offset the risks (described above) created by point solutions and will ultimately lead to true ‘augmented business process automation’ that delivers the utopian efficiencies and outcomes the business user community so badly needs now and in the post pandemic recovery.

About the author

Richard Clarke is Vice Chair of techUK’s Central Government Council and Director at Fivium, the UK’s largest SME provider of bespoke digital platforms and correspondence case management services to the public sector ecosystem. Fuelled by his passion for improving the lives of UK citizens through technology, Richard has developed a deep domain knowledge having spent the last 16 years operating in senior leadership positions within the GovTech sector.

You can read all insights from techUK's Intelligent Automation Week here

Rory Daniels

Rory Daniels

Senior Programme Manager, Emerging Technologies

Rory joined techUK in June 2023 after three years in the Civil Service on its Fast Stream leadership development programme.

During this time, Rory worked on the Government's response to Covid-19 (NHS Test & Trace), school funding strategy (Department for Education) and international climate and nature policy (Cabinet Office). He also tackled the social care crisis whilst on secondment to techUK's Health and Social Care programme in 2022.

Before this, Rory worked in the House of Commons and House of Lords alongside completing degrees in Political Economy and Global Politics.

Today, Rory leads techUK's emerging technologies activity across everything from immersive, web3, AI and robotics to space, gaming & metaverse.

This involves co-running techUK's flagship Innovation campaign, managing four series (including the 'Meet the Innovators' interview series), and launching 4-6-month 'sprint campaigns' on transformative technologies and sectors.

Email:
[email protected]
LinkedIn:
https://www.linkedin.com/in/rorydaniels28/

Read lessmore

Laura Foster

Laura Foster

Associate Director - Technology and Innovation, techUK

Laura is techUK’s Associate Director for Technology and Innovation.

She supports the application and expansion of emerging technologies, including Quantum Computing, High-Performance Computing, AR/VR/XR and Edge technologies, across the UK. As part of this, she works alongside techUK members and UK Government to champion long-term and sustainable innovation policy that will ensure the UK is a pioneer in science and technology

Before joining techUK, Laura worked internationally as a conference researcher and producer covering enterprise adoption of emerging technologies. This included being part of the strategic team at London Tech Week.

Laura has a degree in History (BA Hons) from Durham University, focussing on regional social history. Outside of work she loves reading, travelling and supporting rugby team St. Helens, where she is from.

Email:
[email protected]
LinkedIn:
www.linkedin.com/in/lauraalicefoster

Read lessmore

Elis Thomas

Elis Thomas

Programme Manager, Tech and Innovation, techUK

Elis joined techUK in December 2023 as a Programme Manager for Tech and Innovation, focusing on AI, Semiconductors and Digital ID.

He previously worked at an advocacy group for tech startups, with a regional focus on Wales. This involved policy research on innovation, skills and access to finance.

Elis has a Degree in History, and a Masters in Politics and International Relations from the University of Winchester, with a focus on the digitalisation and gamification of armed conflicts.

Email:
[email protected]
Website:
www.techuk.org/
LinkedIn:
https://www.linkedin.com/in/elis-thomas-49a1aa1a1/

Read lessmore

 

Related topics